McCarthy Creek1405 N. McCarthy Road Appleton, WI 54913920-830-8800

The large, clear lake located in the center of the grounds features a beach for sand castles and swimming, fish for fishing and a breeze for dreaming on a warm afternoon. Across the street, our on site pool is a popular place to take a swim or read a book in the sunshine.

Our newly remodeled community clubhouse now features an updated fitness center, billiards and game room along with a conference room for meetings.

Schedule A Tour

Neighborhood

Nestled in a quiet neighborhood just west of the heart of Appleton’s shopping district and just minutes away from the convenience of Highway 41, the friendly, community-based lifestyle of Toonen Properties will truly convince you that “home is where the heart is.”

Manager Information

Sharan Kapoor

appleton@toonencompanies.com

Features & Amenities

  • Clubhouse
  • Fitness center
  • Wireless internet
  • Heated outdoor pool
  • Social room
  • Recreational lake
  • Community garden plots
  • Professional and caring full-time staff
  • 24-hour emergency maintenance
  • Pet free
  • Smoke free

6 Available Homes

List View
Map View
Narrow Your Search
Reset Filters

1535 N McCarthy Rd Apt 8

  • Unit: 1535-08
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 1.5
  • Square Footage: 1200
  • Floor: Upper
  • Rent: $1,470.00
Upper with Open concept, living dining area with fireplace, office nook, carpeted deck. Master with half bath and walk-in closet. *Video of similar apartment with parking lot view instead of road side view.

1645 N McCarthy Rd Apt 10

  • Unit: 1645-10
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 2.0
  • Square Footage: 1265
  • Floor: Upper
  • Rent: $1,425.00
Upper 2 bed/2 bath with Split Bedroom and Open Concept Living/Dining room. Large patio facing creek

1535 N McCarthy Rd Apt 4

  • Unit: 1535-04
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 1.5
  • Square Footage: 1100
  • Floor: Lower
  • Rent: $1,365.00
Large 2 bedroom lower with open concept living/dining room which has a gas fireplace and an office nook. Master bedroom has half bath and walk in closet. Building has controlled access entry with intercom system.

1635 N McCarthy Rd Apt 8

  • Unit: 1635-08
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 2.0
  • Square Footage: 1375
  • Floor: Lower
  • Rent: $1,555.00
Large 2 bed/2 full bath lower with private entry through an attached garage. Open concept living/dining room, large patio facing spacious yard area with creek. Bedrooms are split on either side of the apartment, each having a full bath attached. Controlled access building.

1665 N McCarthy Rd Apt 3

  • Unit: 1665-03
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 2.0
  • Square Footage: 1265
  • Floor: Upper
  • Rent: $1,395.00
Large 2 bedroom, 2 bath upper. You enter into a foyer area with a nice coat closet. As you head into the kitchen, you notice lots of counterspace and a generous pantry. The living room has a gas fireplace which puts out lots of heat and is really cozy at this time of year! When you head down the hall, you will see the guest bedroom, the first full bath, the laundry room and then the master bedroom which has a bathroom ensuite with walk in shower. This bedroom also gets a walk in closet.

1665 N McCarthy Rd Apt 6

  • Unit: 1665-06
  • Bedrooms: 1
  • Bathrooms: 1.0
  • Square Footage: 1115
  • Floor: Upper
  • Rent: $1,230.00
Large 1 bed upper with huge open concept living/dining room. Large kitchen, Patio facing creek/grassy area. Nice bedroom with walk in closet.All buildings have intercom system and controlled access entry.
Unit Bedrooms Bathrooms Square Footage Rent Available Date Details Link
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1535-08 1535-08 Rent: $1,470.00 Bed: 2 Bath: 1.5 Sq. Ft.: 1200 Floor: Upper Available:
9/11/2026
Details
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1645-10 1645-10 Rent: $1,425.00 Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Sq. Ft.: 1265 Floor: Upper Available:
9/11/2026
Details
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1535-04 1535-04 Rent: $1,365.00 Bed: 2 Bath: 1.5 Sq. Ft.: 1100 Floor: Lower Available:
9/24/2026
Details
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1635-08 1635-08 Rent: $1,555.00 Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Sq. Ft.: 1375 Floor: Lower Available:
10/9/2026
Details
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1665-03 1665-03 Rent: $1,395.00 Bed: 2 Bath: 2.0 Sq. Ft.: 1265 Floor: Upper Available:
10/9/2026
Details
Thumbnail Image for Unit 1665-06 1665-06 Rent: $1,230.00 Bed: 1 Bath: 1.0 Sq. Ft.: 1115 Floor: Upper Available:
11/6/2026
Details

Suggested Properties

Crystal Springs

Appleton 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1075

Elm Grove

Little Chute 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1065

North Shore

Menasha 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1200

Silver Springs

Appleton 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1050

Strata

Appleton 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1335

Tarragon Park

Kaukauna 1 and 2 Bedroom HomesRent starting at $1070